The $48 trophies: how the Grey Cup, Stanley Cup and Brier came to be

Weekly blog: a new post every Tuesday. Don’t forget to sign up for our free weekly newsletter on Substack: sign up here.Our four sites each post once a week: West Lethbridge Weather on Monday, Lethbridge Weather on Tuesday, VE6DOK on Wednesday and Dok-Tor Harddrive on Thursday, with the Prairie Signals newsletter rounding up the week on Friday.

🏆 Congratulations to the Edmonton Elks, 2026 Grey Cup champions! In a back-and-forth thriller at McMahon Stadium in Calgary, the Elks beat the Montreal Alouettes 37–30 to win the 113th Grey Cup, their 15th championship and their first since 2015. Grey Cup MVP Cody Fajardo threw two touchdown passes and ran in two more. Going from last in the West a year ago to champions is quite a turnaround. Well done, Elks!

Every player on that field was chasing a trophy that cost $48. So was every hockey team that has ever chased the Stanley Cup. Canada’s three most famous sports trophies all have surprisingly humble, and sometimes downright comical, stories behind them.

The Grey Cup: the hockey trophy that went to football

The Grey Cup was never meant for football. In 1909, Canada’s Governor General, Albert Grey, the fourth Earl Grey, planned to donate a trophy for the country’s senior amateur hockey championship. Before he could, Sir Montague Allan beat him to it with the Allan Cup. So Earl Grey gave his trophy to amateur rugby football instead, the game that grew into Canadian football. It was made by Birks in Canada at a reported cost of $48.

The first Grey Cup game was played in Toronto on December 4, 1909. The University of Toronto beat the Parkdale Canoe Club 26–6 in front of 3,800 fans. The trophy wasn’t ready on game day, so the winners didn’t actually get it until the following March.

It’s had a rough life since:

  • It survived a 1947 fire that destroyed other artifacts in the same building.
  • In 1967 pranksters stole it from the Hamilton Tiger-Cats and abandoned it three days later.
  • In 1969 it was stolen from Ottawa’s Lansdowne Park and held for ransom. Toronto police later found it in a storage locker at the Royal York Hotel.
  • In 1987 a celebrating Edmonton player sat on it and broke it. It came home from Toronto’s 1991 win with tape holding the neck together, and in 1993 Edmonton’s Blake Dermott broke it again by head-butting it.
  • In 1995 the Baltimore Stallions won it, the only time the Grey Cup has gone to the United States.

Alberta has its own chapter. In 1948, Calgary Stampeders fans famously rode a horse into a hotel lobby on Grey Cup weekend, and in 1975 Calgary hosted the first Grey Cup ever played on the Prairies. Sunday’s game was the sixth in Calgary, and the Elks are taking it home to Edmonton for the 15th time.

The Stanley Cup: a punch bowl and a letter

Lord Stanley of Preston arrived in Canada in 1888 as Governor General. His family took to hockey, and his sons pestered him to give a trophy as “an outward and visible sign of the hockey championship.”

On March 18, 1892, at a dinner celebrating the Ottawa Hockey Club, a letter from Lord Stanley was read out. He wrote that he had “for some time been thinking that it would be a good thing if there were a challenge cup which should be held from year to year by the champion hockey team in the Dominion.”

He bought a silver bowl in London (it was made in Sheffield) for ten guineas, about $48.67 at the time. It was 18.5 cm (7.28 in) tall and 29 cm (11.42 in) across. He had it engraved “Dominion Hockey Challenge Cup,” but everyone simply called it the Stanley Cup. The Montreal Hockey Club won it first, in 1893.

  • It began as a challenge trophy for amateur clubs. In 1910 it became a prize for professional teams.
  • The original bowl was used until 1970 and now sits in the vault at the Hockey Hall of Fame in Toronto. The Cup presented today is a copy of the original.
  • Every champion’s names are engraved on bands around the base. When the bottom band fills up, the oldest band is removed and sent to the Hall of Fame, so the Cup never grows any taller.
  • Lord Stanley went home to England before his Cup was ever awarded, and he never saw a game played for it. He was inducted into the Hockey Hall of Fame in 1945, in its very first class.

The Brier: named after a tobacco brand

Curling’s great trophy has the most unexpected origin of all. In 1924, George J. Cameron, who worked for a company owned by Macdonald Tobacco of Montreal, pitched the idea of a national men’s curling championship. Macdonald first paid for winners of the big Manitoba bonspiel to travel east in 1925 and 1926, and those trips were popular enough to start a full national championship.

The first Brier was played at the Granite Club in Toronto in March 1927, and a Halifax rink skipped by Murray MacNeill won it. Every game that year went 14 ends, and two even needed a 15th to break ties.

  • Why “Brier”? It was the name of one of Macdonald’s tobacco brands. A brier is a small shrub whose roots are carved into tobacco pipes.
  • The silver Brier Tankard, handcrafted in England, was first called the British Consols Trophy, after a Macdonald cigarette brand.
  • Macdonald also started the tradition of the heart-shaped crests given to the curlers, which is where the “hearts” theme in Canadian curling comes from.
  • Macdonald sponsored it until 1979. Labatt took over and introduced a golden stein instead. When Nokia became the sponsor in 2001, the original tankard came back, and the Labatt-era winners were engraved on it too. Since then it’s been the Tim Hortons Brier and, since 2024, the Montana’s Brier.
  • It has been played every year since 1927, except during the Second World War (1943 to 1945).

What they have in common

Two Governors General and a tobacco salesman, two trophies that cost about $48 each, and one named after a pipe root. None of them was meant to become a national treasure. They were simple gifts meant to get Canadians playing one another, and over a century later they still do it better than anything else.

Learn more

Was this page helpful?

Questions or ideas about this post? Email us at help@drhd.com. We read every one.

Get all four of our sites in one free email every Friday: Prairie Signals
⇧Top
Hello! “Success is often just an idea away.”